Paul Hurst’s dozen – the verdict on Ipswich Town new boys so far

PUBLISHED: 16:03 05 September 2018 | UPDATED: 16:03 05 September 2018

Janci Donacien in action against Aston Villa. Photo: Steve Waller

Janci Donacien in action against Aston Villa. Photo: Steve Waller

© Copyright Stephen Waller

There’s been a complete squad overhaul under new boss Paul Hurst. Stuart Watson gives his verdict on how the 12 new signings have started at Ipswich Town.

Janoi Donacien

Signed on loan from Accrington Stanley but is set to become a permanent addition – for an agreed fee of around £750k – once some work permits issues are sorted, hopefully before the trip to Hull a week on Saturday.

He operated as a left-back for much of last season, made his Town debut at centre-half against Blackburn Rovers, but was soon switched to right-back – the position manager Paul Hurst always had in mind for the man with the No,2 on his back.

MORE: Ex West Ham defender Collins training with Blues

At times the 26-year-old has maybe got a little too tight to his man, and it would be nice to see a little more offensively, but he’s certainly not looked out of is depth after stepping up from League Two to the Championship.

He kept Aston Villa danger man Albert Adomah quiet in the 1-1 home draw, then handled tricky former Blues loanee Tom Lawrence pretty well in the 2-0 defeat at Derby County. Okay, Sheffield Wednesday wide man Lucas Joao scored twice in the 2-1 defeat at Hillsborough, but it still came as a surprise when Jordan Spence was preferred to him for Sunday’s 1-1 East Anglian derby draw with Norwich.

Match ratings: 665876

Toto Nsiala slides in on Villa's Albert Adomah. Photo: Steve WallerToto Nsiala slides in on Villa's Albert Adomah. Photo: Steve Waller

Toto Nsiala

Links back up with long-term mentor Paul Hurst following spells under his management at Grimsby Town and Shrewsbury Town.

An athletic, rugged centre-back who simply loves to defend. He can leap to win headers in either box and use his pace to mop up at the back. Physically he’s looked every inch the part, but the 26-year-old – who has previously played in the National League, League Two and League One – is learning what you can and can’t get away with in the Championship.

MORE: ‘I do wonder what the future holds... hopefully the owner will be in contact’ – Knudsen on contract situation

He gave away costly free-kicks against Rotherham and Derby (arguably harshly done by for both), while he was also dismissed for a tackle on Fernando Forestieri at Sheffield Wednesday (a complete miscarriage of justice).

Players at this level are that bit quicker and cannier though and Nsiala may have to curb his slide tackling instinct slightly (not easy) to prevent referees having a decision to make.

Match ratings: 77767

Everton loanee Matthew Pennington enjoyed a fine debut against Norwich. Photo: Steve WallerEverton loanee Matthew Pennington enjoyed a fine debut against Norwich. Photo: Steve Waller

Matthew Pennington

Joined on a season-long loan from Everton just moments before the window shut at 5pm last Friday.

The 23-year-old has made nine appearances for his boyhood club (including scoring a goal in a Merseyside Derby) and got taste of the Championship last season when on loan at Leeds (15 starts and nine sub appearances on loan).

He was thrown straight into the starting line-up for Sunday’s East Anglian derby at Portman Road, replacing the suspended Nsiala at centre-back, and was up there in terms of man-of-the-match candidates after producing an assured display.

MORE: Eight Ipswich Town questions that must be answered after the international break

Deceptively quick, reads the game well and provided some decent raking balls forwards. With skipper Luke Chambers having started every league game so far, it’s going to be fascinating to see who ends up being the centre-back pairing of choice, especially if veteran defender James Collins – currently training with the club – signs as a free agent in the coming days.

Match ratings: 8

Trevoh Chalobah celevrates his goal against Aston Villa. Photo: Steve WallerTrevoh Chalobah celevrates his goal against Aston Villa. Photo: Steve Waller

Trevoh Chalobah

The Chelsea loanee may only be 19 but he has some real pedigree. Was on the bench for the FA Cup Final last May, trained with England’s senior squad prior to the World Cup and then captained the Under-19s at the European Championships.

He may well end up a centre-back, like his older brother Nathaniel at Watford, but Hurst has used him primarily as a holding midfielder during these early steps into men’s football.

MORE: What a move and what a strike! – Watch Danny Rowe finish off a spectacular move for Town’s Under-23s

You can see the huge potential. There’s been plenty of swagger but also a fair bit of sloppiness. He sent his spot-kick well wide at Exeter, but hooked home an equaliser against Villa. Undoubtedly, he has tended to fade around the 70 minute mark of games.

Going to be fun to watching him grow as the season goes on.

Match ratings: 7767567

Tayo Edun is on a season-long loan from Fulham. Photo: Steve WallerTayo Edun is on a season-long loan from Fulham. Photo: Steve Waller

Tayo Edun

Diminutive, versatile left-footer with a lovely low centre of gravity.

The 20-year-old – on a season-long loan from newly-promoted Fulham – scored on his debut when his cross crept in at the far post for a dramatic late leveller against Blackburn.

He played on the left wing when stepping off the bench that day, but has since played as a central midfielder – his preferred position. Was full of energy, tenacity and positive intent at Exeter before fading, then was harshly dismissed for two yellow cards just before half-time of the Aston Villa draw.

MORE: ‘His know-how will be crucial for us’ – Hurst on Walters

Did okay on his return at Hillsborough and then was dropped for the visit of Norwich. Looks to be very a useful squad asset.

Match ratings: 77866

Jon Nolan is reunited with Paul Hurst at Ipswich Town following a move from Shrewsbury. Photo: Steve WallerJon Nolan is reunited with Paul Hurst at Ipswich Town following a move from Shrewsbury. Photo: Steve Waller

Jon Nolan

Close ball control, tight turning circle, treats the ball with care and capable of both spotting and executing a forward pass.

Hurst was desperate to be reunited with his former Shrewsbury star man and, technically, he does look every inch the Championship player.

The 26-year-old still seems to be getting up to the speed of this level though. He needs to be more involved in games and support the front men more. Looks capable of chipping in with his fair share of goals.

Match ratings: 778666

Gwion Edwards

Flying Welsh winger has produced some dazzling displays on the right.

Gwion Edwards has produced some dazzling wing displays. Photo: Steve WallerGwion Edwards has produced some dazzling wing displays. Photo: Steve Waller

Headed home just five minutes into his debut and then had us all cooing with one audacious flick and run. Woodwork denied him a super goal against Villa, then he frightened the Norwich defence with his directness throughout. Deflected finish against the Canaries further cements his status as new fans’ favourite.

MORE: ‘The fans have got to stick with it... I’m sure we’ll be fine’ – Paul Hurst on Town’s winless start

There have been quieter games, as can be the case with old-fashioned wingers, but he certainly looks a snip at £700k from League Two side Peterborough. At last Town have a crowd-pleaser they can call their own.

Match ratings: 877567

Jordan Graham

Arrived on a season-long loan from Wolves last week. The 23-year-old, who had a very brief spell at Town back in 2013, will be looking to rediscover the sparkling form he produced pre long-term injury midway through the 2015/16 campaign. During that purple patch he produced a string of assists and man-of-the-match displays.

Went straight into the team against Norwich but failed to make much impact out on the left. Was booked for a dive in the box, while his set-piece deliveries were a mixed bag.

Jordan Graham went straight into the team after joining on loan from Wolves. Photo: Steve WallerJordan Graham went straight into the team after joining on loan from Wolves. Photo: Steve Waller

Match ratings: 5

Jordan Roberts

A Bosman free transfer signing from League Two side Crawley, Roberts is probably seen as more of a long-term project.

The 24-year-old, who can play wide left or up front, loves to take on his marker and get crosses or shots away. Restricted to two sub appearances so far, including a bright cameo at Derby.

Match ratings: 67

Jon Walters

Jordan Roberts has been restricted to two substitute appearances so far. Photo: PagepixJordan Roberts has been restricted to two substitute appearances so far. Photo: Pagepix

Former Town favourite is back at Portman Road as a loan addition from Burnley.

The 34-year-old striker has been drafted in until January to provide some much-needed experience and leadership – both on and off the pitch.

Since departing Portman Road in 2010, he had racked up 226 appearances in the Premier League for Stoke and made 53 caps for the Republic of Ireland.

May have missed most of last year through injury, but looked fit and sharp when playing the full match against Norwich. Could be the shrewdest addition of the lot.

Match ratings: 8

Kayden Jackson

Striker with a reputation as being one of the quickest in the business, he scored 16 goals in League Two for Accrington Stanley last season. At £1.6m he was Town’s most expensive signing in almost a decade.

Jon Walters is back at Ipswich Town - on loan from Burnley. Photo: Steve WallerJon Walters is back at Ipswich Town - on loan from Burnley. Photo: Steve Waller

Began by playing the role of impact sub, but has started the last two games. Closes down defenders quickly, has an aggressive edge and makes selfless runs into the channels. Yet to really catch the eye though.

Hopefully there is a lot more to come from the new No.9.

Match ratings: 676666

Ellis Harrison

Welshman has been schooled in the art of forward play by Town hero Marcus Stewart at Bristol Rovers.

From what we’ve seen so far, the 24-year-old – who cost £750k – he looks a decent all-rounder. He’s quick enough, can hold the ball up and is strong in the air for his height.

You have to say he hasn’t quite replicated his impressive pre-season display against West Ham. So often he looked isolated when leading the line on his own. Indeed, he was probably more threatening when used as a makeshift left-winger at Sheffield Wednesday.

Kayden Jackson shields the ball at Sheffield Wednesday. Photo: PagepixKayden Jackson shields the ball at Sheffield Wednesday. Photo: Pagepix

Faces serious competition now Walters has arrived.

Match ratings: 757576

Most Read

Latest from the Green Un

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists