Stuart Watson's Sunday Verdict: Ipswich Town aren't bottom because of referees and bad luck

PUBLISHED: 17:09 27 January 2019

Flynn Downes and Matthew Pennington both appeal to referee Keith Stroud during Ipswich Town's 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa. Photo: Pagepix

Flynn Downes and Matthew Pennington both appeal to referee Keith Stroud during Ipswich Town's 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa. Photo: Pagepix

Pagepix Ltd 07976 935738

Ipswich Town remain seven points adrift of safety at the foot of the Championship table following Saturday's 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa. Chief football writer STUART WATSON has his final say on the weekend.

Bartosz Bialkowski is beaten by Tammy Abraham's close-range finish as Villa take an early lead. Photo: PagepixBartosz Bialkowski is beaten by Tammy Abraham's close-range finish as Villa take an early lead. Photo: Pagepix

Time to pick your own ‘luck’ cliche.

‘You never get the rub of the green when you’re down at the bottom’.

‘Luck evens itself over the course of the season’.

‘You make your own luck (and the table doesn’t lie)’.

Ipswich keeper Bartosz Bialkowski is sent the wrong way by Tammy Abraham from the penalty spot as Villa take a 2-0 lead Picture PagepixIpswich keeper Bartosz Bialkowski is sent the wrong way by Tammy Abraham from the penalty spot as Villa take a 2-0 lead Picture Pagepix

It’s a debate pertinent to Ipswich Town after a fourth penalty was awarded against them in five league leagues.

Alan Judge certainly wasn’t afforded the luck of the Irish when he was punished for the crime of standing a little bit close to an opponent in the Aston Villa penalty box on Saturday.

Referee Keith Stroud bought John McGinn’s dramatic arms-spread aeroplane impersonation hook, line and sinker. Tammy Abraham sent Bartosz Bialkowski the wrong way form the spot. 2-0. Game over. Or so it seemed.

That’s generally been the script for Town (who have lost by that scoreline seven times on their travels this season). Not on this occasion though. They rallied. Villa wobbled.

Striker Collin Quaner's shot is blocked by the last man after being put through on goal at Aston Villa and going around the keeper - But blocked with what?  Picture PagepixStriker Collin Quaner's shot is blocked by the last man after being put through on goal at Aston Villa and going around the keeper - But blocked with what? Picture Pagepix

Stroud then ignored Town’s appeals for a penalty of their own after Collin Quaner rounded the keeper and saw his low shot blocked by the trailing arm of a sliding Tommy Elphick.

Freddie Sears scored a 25-yard screamer, Trevoh Chalobah hit the post and the Town players walked off feeling mightily aggrieved at the man in black.

Paul Lambert, once again sans coat and wet right through, displayed steam-out-of-the-ears, high-pitched animated anger which was almost cartoon-like.

He stormed off and was spotted turning the air blue in the tunnel on his way to seek out Stroud. It’s just as well he didn’t see/hear Villa boss Dean Smith’s subsequent perplexed expression when quizzed about the two major incidents during his own press conference.

Lambert’s ‘it wouldn’t look out place in the NBA’ was countered with ‘I didn’t see anything wrong with that’.

Lambert’s ‘that’s never a penalty for Villa’ was countered with ‘Judge grabbed him around the neck’.

Football. It’s certainly a game of opinions.

Right now it feels like everything that could have gone against Ipswich has done this season; Tayo Edun’s red card against Villa at Portman Road, two heavily deflected goals at Derby, Toto Nsiala’s ridiculous dismissal at Sheffield Wednesday, Jon Walters’ injury against Bolton...

Striker Collin Quaner appeals for hand ball at Aston Villa. Picture:  PAGEPIX LTDStriker Collin Quaner appeals for hand ball at Aston Villa. Picture: PAGEPIX LTD

And that’s before we get onto the recent penalties – all of which are of varying degrees of ‘soft’.

However, for context, 14 teams have conceded more spot-kicks than Ipswich (5) in the Championship this season. Wigan (12), Blackburn (12) and Swansea (10) are all into double figures.

Ipswich Town aren’t bottom of the Championship and seven points adrift of safety because of referees and bad luck.

They are where they are because they failed to beat 10-man Bolton and Preston at home, because they managed to lose from winning positions against both Bristol City and Millwall at home, because they’ve conceded so many goals away... the list goes on.

Ipswich captain Luke Chambers commiserates with the travelling supporters at Villa Park - gesturing that it all hinged on a hand-ball decision which wasn't given. Picture: PAGEPIX LTDIpswich captain Luke Chambers commiserates with the travelling supporters at Villa Park - gesturing that it all hinged on a hand-ball decision which wasn't given. Picture: PAGEPIX LTD

All the talk about Stroud this weekend rather overlooks the fact that Villa had 23 shots, Bartosz Bialkowski made 11 saves and the Blues’ purple patches in the game were just that.

That’s the galling thing – Town have proved they can play, sadly just for not long enough in games. Spells of pressure are rarely sustained. And the fine margins at the business ends of the pitch continually tip the wrong way.

It looks like someone will stay up with one of the lowest points totals in recent history.

Town can’t rely on referees and they can’t rely on others to get themselves out of this hole. What they can do is use any sense of injustice and the gap having not widened as motivational fuel for the 17 games ahead.

Freddie Sears celebrates his second half strike at Villa Park Picture PagepixFreddie Sears celebrates his second half strike at Villa Park Picture Pagepix

It was a spirited finish to Saturday’s game. Now we need a spirited finish to the season.

Trevoh Chalobah's second half header strikes the post at Aston Villa Picture PagepixTrevoh Chalobah's second half header strikes the post at Aston Villa Picture Pagepix

Ipswich Town captain Luke Chambers is left disappointed following Saturday's 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa Photo: PagepixIpswich Town captain Luke Chambers is left disappointed following Saturday's 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa Photo: Pagepix

Ipswich keeper Bartosz Bialkowski makes his way off the pitch at Aston Villa Picture PagepixIpswich keeper Bartosz Bialkowski makes his way off the pitch at Aston Villa Picture Pagepix

Most Read

Most Read

Latest from the Green Un

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists